| Date | Details | Results | Alerts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 03/19/12 05:00 pm | @Westfield (5-15) Westfield High School | W2-1 | |
| 03/27/12 05:00 pm | @Speedway (11-16) Speedway | W11-1 | |
| 04/09/12 04:00 pm | Cloverdale (8-9) Monrovia | L5-0 | |
| 04/10/12 05:00 pm | @Cloverdale (8-9) Cloverdale | W6-0 | |
| 04/12/12 05:00 pm | @Indianapolis Cardinal Ritter (9-18) Eagledale | W10-1 | |
| 04/13/12 05:30 pm | @Mooresville (8-14-1) Pioneer Field | L9-2 | |
| 04/17/12 05:00 pm | South Putnam (31-0) South Putnam | L12-0 | |
| 04/17/12 07:00 pm | @South Putnam (31-0) South Putnam | L5-0 | |
| 04/18/12 04:30 pm | Owen Valley (5-21) Monrovia | W10-0 | |
| 04/19/12 05:00 pm | @Brown County (20-6) Brown County High School | L1-0 | |
| 04/21/12 11:00 am | Indian Creek (8-12) Monrovia | L3-1 | |
| 04/23/12 05:00 pm | Danville Community (10-18) Monrovia | L8-7 | |
| 04/26/12 05:00 pm | Edgewood (21-12) Monrovia | L3-1 | |
| 04/30/12 05:00 pm | @Greencastle (7-15) | W11-1 | |
| 05/01/12 05:00 pm | Greencastle (7-15) | W5-1 | |
| 05/03/12 05:00 pm | Eminence (10-8) Monrovia | L4-3 | |
| 05/08/12 05:00 pm | @North Putnam (4-16) North Putnam | W13-1 | |
| 05/10/12 05:00 pm | Bethesda Christian (13-7) Monrovia | W10-0 | |
| 05/11/12 05:00 pm | North Putnam (4-16) Monrovia | W5-1 | |
| 05/14/12 05:00 pm | @Cascade (24-5) Cadet Fields | L7-0 | |
| 05/15/12 05:00 pm | Cascade (24-5) Monrovia | L5-1 | |
| 05/17/12 05:00 pm | Plainfield (23-9) Monrovia | L10-0 | |
| 05/21/12 05:30 pm | Speedway (11-16) Cascade Sectional | W5-1 | |
| 05/22/12 05:30 pm | @Cascade (24-5) Cascade (Sectional) | L9-0 |
