| Date | Details | Results | Alerts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 04/03/12 05:00 pm | East Noble (13-7) Garrett High School | L7-2 | |
| 04/04/12 05:00 pm | Angola (21-8) Garrett | L6-0 | |
| 04/06/12 04:00 pm | @Bellmont (2-9) Bellmont | Pregame | Alert Me! |
| 04/09/12 06:00 pm | Fremont (12-15) Garrett | W4-3 | |
| 04/11/12 06:00 pm | @Columbia City (6-4) Columbia City | Pregame | Alert Me! |
| 04/12/12 04:30 pm | @Carroll (Fort Wayne) (7-8) Carroll | W8-2 | |
| 04/16/12 05:00 pm | Fairfield (23-8) Garrett | L9-0 | |
| 04/18/12 04:30 pm | @Hamilton (0-18) Hamilton | W10-2 | |
| 04/19/12 06:00 pm | Woodlan (31-2) Garrett | L4-0 | |
| 04/20/12 04:00 pm | @DeKalb (5-9) DeKalb Cty Showdown | Pregame | Alert Me! |
| 04/21/12 10:00 am | @Eastside (6-13) DeKalb Cty Showdown | Pregame | Alert Me! |
| 04/21/12 12:00 pm | @Lakewood Park Christian (26-5) DeKalb Cty Showdown | L12-2 | |
| 04/23/12 06:00 pm | Lakeland (20-13) Garrett | W8-4 | |
| 04/24/12 04:00 pm | Leo (26-3) Garrett | L4-2 | |
| 04/26/12 05:00 pm | @Adams Central (13-8) Adams Central | Pregame | Alert Me! |
| 04/30/12 04:30 pm | @Churubusco (11-16) Churubusco | L3-0 | |
| 05/01/12 06:00 pm | South Adams (11-19) Garrett HS | W4-1 | |
| 05/03/12 05:00 pm | @Bluffton (3-10) Bluffton | Pregame | Alert Me! |
| 05/04/12 04:00 pm | @Concordia Lutheran, Fort Wayne (9-6) Concordia | Pregame | Alert Me! |
| 05/05/12 10:00 am | Fort Wayne Bishop Dwenger (17-7) Garrett | L6-0 | |
| 05/05/12 02:00 pm | Manchester (10-14) Garrett | W6-1 | |
| 05/05/12 06:00 pm | Elkhart Memorial (2-9) Garrett Invitational | Pregame | Alert Me! |
| 05/08/12 06:00 pm | Southern Wells (1-17) Garrett | Pregame | Alert Me! |
| 05/10/12 06:00 pm | Heritage (12-12) Garrett | W7-1 | |
| 05/14/12 05:00 pm | @Central Noble (16-15) Central Noble | L6-2 | |
| 05/15/12 06:00 pm | Homestead (19-10) Garrett | L2-1 | |
| 05/16/12 05:00 pm | @Prairie Heights (11-12) Prarie Heights | W11-8 | |
| 05/19/12 10:00 am | Fort Wayne Snider (4-8) Garrett | Pregame | Alert Me! |
| 05/19/12 12:00 pm | Fort Wayne Snider (4-8) Garrett | Pregame | Alert Me! |
| 05/23/12 07:00 pm | Woodlan (31-2) Leo | L5-0 |
